Matchday WED 18 NOV

MLB

Ohtani and Harper face a steep climb in the NL MVP race

Pete Crow-Armstrong leads the National League MVP race with a 65% winning probability, leaving Shohei Ohtani with a 35% chance. The competition between Ohtani and Bryce Harper depends on whether voters prioritize Ohtani's two-way production or Harper's elite offensive rate production.

Ohtani and Harper face a steep climb in the NL MVP race

PCA leads the current race

Pete Crow-Armstrong leads the National League MVP race with a 65% winning probability. He leads in most hitting stats and holds a significant lead in WAR. Shohei Ohtani has a 35% winning probability. To win, Ohtani needs to reach 100 innings, 10 wins, and 100 strikeouts following his September return as a pitcher. He must also create a large gap in OPS, home runs, and batting average to overcome the WAR deficit. PCA can win if he maintains his current form without letting his hitting stats drop. He can even win if he does not lead in OPS or home runs, provided he maintains this gap in WAR. This race is unprecedented because hitting stats stay nearly even, leaving the comparison to rely on pitching and defensive stats.

I see a massive gap in the betting markets. Bryce Harper sits at 0.1% in the 2026 NL MVP market, while PCA holds 97.5%. The 2021 National League MVP race demonstrated that a player can win the award with overwhelming slugging and OPS even if they trail another candidate like Juan Soto by 1.4 in rWAR, despite a mere 0.1 difference in fWAR. Juan Soto also recorded the most walks in the league and one of the best on-base percentages in modern baseball. Fernando Tatis Jr. won the home run title that year. I also recall the 2012 AL MVP race where Miguel Cabrera won the Triple Crown even though Mike Trout posted a historic 10.0 WAR. Voters often favor players who achieve elite rate production or hit 35 home runs. They look for players who combine multiple years in the five to seven WAR range with elite offensive production.

Player Team Wins Losses Win %
Shohei Ohtani Dodgers 100 62 .617
Bryce Harper Phillies 88 74 .543

The current debate focuses on whether the best defense wins or the two-way player prevails. Historical examples show that massive WAR advantages do not always secure the award. In 2021, the difference in fWAR between Harper and Soto was only 0.1, yet Harper won. Modern voters look at hard hit rate, strikeout and walk profiles, sprint speed, and defensive positioning to differentiate candidates. They favor players who check every column and play under bright, tense lights in September.

NL landscape and the DH rule

The National League still lacks a universal designated hitter because the Phillies representative voted against it in 1980. A fishing trip and game theory swayed that decision. This absence forces players to handle more defensive responsibilities. The Dodgers have 100 wins and 62 losses, while the Phillies have 88 wins and 74 losses, trailing the Braves by 6.0 games. You know that team relevance matters when ballots go live.

The competition between Ohtani and Harper rests on conflicting philosophies of value. Ohtani’s Dodgers pursue a pennant with 100 wins, while Harper’s Phillies chase the division from 6.0 games back. The Phillies’ lack of a DH remains a direct result of that failed 1980 vote. I find the lack of a universal DH in the National League to be a strange historical relic. Will the Dodgers’ World Series push pull Ohtani past the Cubs’ star?

Back to top