Why Wilfried Nancy’s Columbus Crew November playoff push matters now
Wilfried Nancy's Columbus Crew holds 35 points in 30 matches and sits 11th in the Eastern Conference following a 4-0-1 run in their last five games. The team seeks to maintain its tactical identity after selling Cucho Hernandez for 16 million dollars and acquiring Daniel Gazdag.
Tactical identity and roster shifts
Wilfried Nancy utilizes a 3-4-3 system that employs three center backs to control the pitch. These defenders move the ball from the back or use the wings to flank the opposition. This tactical approach secured the MLS Cup for the Crew against LAFC. The club managed a financial shift by selling Cucho Hernandez to Real Betis for 16 million dollars and gained 3.5 million dollars in extra gate revenue when they hosted Inter Miami in Cleveland on Easter Weekend. The team then spent 4.5 million dollars to acquire Philadelphia Union star Daniel Gazdag. Nancy earned MLS Coach of the Year honors in 2024 after guiding the club to a CONCACAF Champions Cup final. Before arriving in Columbus, Nancy led CF Montreal to their highest ever result in the standings as head coach. He previously served as an assistant manager for the Montreal club for three seasons starting in 2016. The Crew won their first title in 2008, though many in the league viewed it as a one-off. The club’s decision to sell Cucho Hernandez was a major move, as he was the 2023 MLS Cup MVP. Nancy’s Crew remains ready for another run at the Cup this season as long as players buy into his strategy.
The managerial vacuum
Nancy’s move to Celtic failed after just 33 days in charge. He lost six of his eight games in Scotland, including 3-1 defeats to both Rangers and St. Mirren in the League Cup final. The club terminated his contract with immediate effect, and head of football operations Paul Tisdale also left the club. Russell Martin now leads the recruitment process for the vacant managerial position in Ohio. Martin previously left Ibrox after a difficult spell. You already know how much a tactical identity matters to this roster, so the vacancy in Columbus feels even more significant. Will the Crew find a successor who follows his philosophical style?
The push for the standings
The Crew currently hold 35 points in 30 matches, placing them 11th in the Eastern Conference, just one point behind Toronto FC which has 36 points and 46 goals scored. During their last five matches, the Crew went 4-0-1 and outscored opponents 11-5. They secured a 2-0 win against FC Cincinnati in the Hell is Real Derby but lost to St. Louis CITY in the U.S. Open Cup final shootout.
Diego Rossi leads the team with 6 goals in 15 matches, while Brais Mendez has 5 goals and 3 assists in 13 matches. Taha Habroune has 5 goals and 4 assists across 29 matches, and Max Arfsten has 4 goals and 4 assists. The squad faces depth issues as Wessam Abou Ali remains out with a knee injury and Rudy Camacho is sidelined with a torso injury.
Toronto’s attack includes Daniel Salloi, who has 8 goals and 7 assists in 30 matches, and Josh Sargent, who has 7 goals in 23 appearances, while Djordje Mihailovic has 3 goals and 5 assists in 15 appearances. The Crew allowed 47 goals, while Toronto allowed 55. The Crew goal difference is -1, which is better than Toronto’s -9, and the Crew score 0.75 goals on average in both the first and second halves. The Crew scored 46 goals this season, which is identical to the total for Toronto, and they also scored against Inter Miami and Charlotte recently. Toronto also has 12 draws, which is tied for the most in the East.
| Match Type | Opponent | Result |
|---|---|---|
| MLS | FC Cincinnati | 2-0 Win |
| U.S. Open Cup | St. Louis CITY | 0-0 Draw (Loss) |
| MLS | Toronto FC | 4-2 Win |