A.J. Hinch vs Dave Roberts: Comparing managerial impact
Dave Roberts leads the comparison against A.J. Hinch after reaching 1,000 career wins and leading the Dodgers to a 104-58 record. While Hinch has led Detroit to recent postseason appearances, Roberts demonstrates higher sustained success through his division titles.
Career milestones reached
A.J. Hinch and DaveLiao Roberts both reached the 1,000 career win milestone this season. Hinch reached the mark after a 7-3 Detroit victory over the Yankees, which brings his career total to 1,000 wins across three different organizations. Hinch, age 52, has managed the Tigers since before the 2021 season and previously managed the Diamondbacks and the Astros. His 1,000 wins include 430 victories in Detroit, 481 with Houston, and 89 in Arizona. Roberts achieved his 1,000th win during a 9-3 Dodgers victory against the Athletics and became the fastest manager in modern history to reach that milestone in 1,606 games. Roberts has led the Dodgers since 2016 and became the fourth Dodgers skipper to win 1,000 games. This achievement follows a season where the Dodgers went 19-4 without Clayton Kershaw. Justin Wrobleski secured his 10th win for the Dodgers during that milestone game by striking out 11 hitters. Hinch now joins the 68th manager in big-league history to reach this mark.
Manager of the year voting results
The National League Manager of the Year voting results show significant differences in team win totals and final points. Pat Murphy of the Milwaukee Brewers won the National League award with 124 points and 20 first-place votes after he led his team to 103 wins and their first World Series title. Murphy became the first manager to win the award three consecutive times. Dave Roberts finished fifth in that National League race with seven total points from two second-place votes and one third-place vote. His Dodgers club posted a 104-58 record, yet they lost 11 of their last 16 games. The American League winner, Will Venable, led the White Sox to 84 wins and a playoff berth with 111 voting points. Venable led the White Sox to a significant turnaround from their previous 100-loss seasons. In the American League, the runners-up were Kevin Cash with 98 points and Chad Tracy with 47 points. Other National League finalists included Walt Weiss with 86 points, Don Mattingly with 25 points, and Craig Stammen with 24 points. You should note that Roberts finished fifth despite his team having more wins than the American League winner. How can a team with 104 wins finish so far behind in the voting?
| Manager | League | Wins | Award Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pat Murphy | NL | 103 | 124 |
| Will Venable | AL | 84 | 111 |
| Dave Roberts | NL | 104 | 7 |
| Kevin Cash | AL | N/A | 98 |
Comparing managerial impact
Hinch continues to build a young core in Detroit, where he has led the Tigers to postseason appearances in both 2024 and 2025. The Tigers hold a 36-49 record and sit fourth in the American League Central. In contrast, Roberts led the Dodgers to their first World Series since 1988. Roberts finished in the top three of the Manager of the Year voting in every season since 2016 except for 2025. He earned 55 points in 2022 after his team finished with 104 wins. Dave Roberts comes out ahead in the comparison because his 104-win season and 1,000th career victory demonstrate a much higher level of sustained success than the 36-49 record currently held by Detroit Tigers manager A.J. Hinch. Hinch, who entered the league after his selection in the third round of the 1996 MLB Draft out of Stanford, manages a different organization than Roberts. Roberts also won the award in 2016. The Dodgers also won their fifth consecutive division title by a margin of 11 games after a strong late season.