Matchday FRI 20 NOV

NFL

Risks in Mike Tomlin’s 2026 Steelers quarterback transition

Aaron Rodgers' potential retirement poses an immediate threat to the Steelers following a season where he threw 24 touchdowns. The franchise faces uncertainty as they weigh the development of Drew Allar against inconsistent options like Mason Rudolph and Will Howard.

Risks in Mike Tomlin's 2026 Steelers quarterback transition

The Rodgers retirement gamble

The Steelers rely on 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers, who completed 65.7% of his passes for 3322 yards, 24 touchdowns, and 7 interceptions during the last season. I view his potential retirement as the most immediate threat to the franchise. The team spent the 2025 offseason preparing for a Rodgers return, yet his age and football addiction make his longevity uncertain. This gamble follows a controversial 2025 draft where the team passed on Jaxson Dart, a player Rod Woodson claimed possessed elite ability to make plays in and out of the pocket. The team instead selected defensive tackle Derrick Harmon with the 21st overall pick. I notice they prioritized the defensive line over the passing game. The team’s decision to prioritize defensive depth over a mobile playmaker like Jaxson Dart suggests a reliance on old-school philosophies that may not work with a modern offensive scheme. The squad saw Rodgers struggle in a 30-6 playoff loss to the Houston Texans. McCarthy actually has a history with Rodgers, having won a Super Bowl with him as a quarterback. If Rodgers decides to retire, the organization loses the primary reason they recruited him. Will the team struggle if Rodgers walks away after this season?

Offensive development failures

The offensive unit carries heavy baggage from the previous coaching staff. I see the failure to develop young talent as a massive hurdle for Mike McCarthy. Roman Wilson, a former third-round pick, missed nearly his entire rookie season due to injuries and later fell out of favor with both Mike Tomlin and Aaron Rodgers. This lack of usage relegated him to a healthy scratch during the 2025 training camp. Broderick Jones also faced difficulties, as he struggled with pass protection during his first two seasons at right tackle before a neck injury derailed his campaign. Kaleb Johnson similarly lost his offensive role after a kickoff blunder in Week 2 of last season. The previous regime’s tendency to jam square pegs into round holes effectively stalled the careers of several high-priority draft picks. Because Tomlin maintained significant control over the offense, these developmental failures fall squarely on his leadership. The lack of offensive production under the previous staff prompted fans to grow restless because they faced constant mediocrity in recent seasons. These coaching decisions meant that players like Jones and Wilson had to struggle against a system that did not suit their specific skills.

The QB depth chart

The roster holds three primary options for the post-Rodgers era. I believe the team lacks a clear path forward among these choices.

Player Status College Stats/Note
Drew Allar 3rd Round Pick 7402 yards, 61 TDs
Mason Rudolph 9th-Year Veteran N/A
Will Howard Young Prospect N/A

The team drafted Drew Allar with the 76th overall pick at Acrisure Stadium to provide long-term relief. Allar finished his college career with a 26-9 record, 7402 passing yards, 61 touchdowns, 13 interceptions, and 12 rushing touchdowns. He faces immediate competition from ninth-year veteran Mason Rudolph and Will Howard. I find the prospect of relying on Howard or Rudolph to be a significant risk given their inconsistent track records. The current staff under McCarthy expects players to show versatility and adaptability rather than following one specific gameplan. This shift aims to help players like Allar and Howard reach their potential, but the transition remains untested. The offense relies on playmakers like George Pickens and Najee Harris to carry the load during this transition. The current depth chart places Mason Rudolph as the second option behind Rodgers, while Will Howard sits as the third. If the team cannot develop Allar into a starter, they will face the same quarterback purgatory they experienced after the retirement of Ben Roethisberger.

Back to top