The economics of Myles Garrett’s $204.8 million contract extension
Myles Garrett signed a four-year extension worth $204.8 million, setting a new record for the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history. This deal averages $40 million annually and follows a season where Garrett recorded 23 sacks.
Myles Garrett signed a four-year extension worth $204.8 million, making him the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history. The deal averages $40 million per year and includes $122.8 million in guarantees. This contract follows Garrett’s 23-sack season, which set a new single-season sack record. He is a consistent All-Pro presence. Garrett holds 102.5 career sacks with the Browns and produced 239 quarterback hits in 134 games. His performance results in 1.7 hits per game, meaning an opposing quarterback faces a hit twice every Sunday. Garrett earned 13.5 sacks in 2018, falling just one sack short of the record held by Reggie Camp. Through his first three seasons, he accrued 30.5 sacks, placing him seventh on the Browns’ all-time list. This contract surpasses the previous non-quarterback record held by Maxx Crosby, who signed a three-year, $106.5 million extension last week. Garrett, a 2017 first-round pick, is a six-time Pro Bowler. Garrett also recorded 22 tackles for loss last season. Garrett turns 30 this December. Even after his trade request in February, Garrett insisted his focus remains on winning rather than money.
Reworked terms and Rams acquisition
The Los Angeles Rams acquired Garrett in a trade for Jared Verse and three draft picks, including a 2027 first-round selection, a 2028 second-round selection, and a 2029 third-round selection. If the Rams trade Garrett to another team in the AFC North, that 2029 pick becomes a first-rounder. The Rams reworked his contract to increase his 2026 compensation from $31.5 million to at least $37 million. This move signals that the Rams prioritize a Super Bowl window around Matthew Stafford, especially since they hold +550 odds to win the title.
| Contract Detail | Value/Specification |
|---|---|
| Total Value | $204.8 million |
| Annual Average | $40 million |
| Total Guarantees | $122.8 million |
| 2026 Compensation | $37 million |
| Trade Return | Jared Verse + 3 picks |
The Browns and Garrett previously modified contract language to move option bonuses from the 15th day of the league year to seven days before the regular season. This change gives Cleveland more flexibility to create additional cap space each year. Garrett’s agent, Nicole Lynn, and Browns GM Andrew Berry worked for 36 hours to finalize the extension. This agreement arrived two days after reports that owner Jimmy Haslam declined a request to meet with Garrett regarding his trade request. You already know the Browns struggle with cap gymnastics when managing veteran contracts.
Cleveland’s defensive spending shifts
Cleveland released defensive tackle Dalvin Tomlinson to save $6 million in salary cap space. This move follows the team’s decision to sign Jameis Winston for up to $8.7 million and Nyheim Hines for up to $3.5 million. Tomlinson was due over $22 million during the next two seasons, so his exit creates a void in the defensive line. The Browns drafted Mike Hall Jr. in the second round last year to eventually replace Tomlinson. Hall played in only half of last season’s games due to injuries and off-field issues. Losing a player like Garrett strips the defense of its primary identity and forces the team to rely on younger talent. Will the Browns find enough depth to replace an All-Pro pass rusher?
The Browns’ roster construction focuses on balancing talent with stability. Following Deshaun Watson’s shoulder injury, the team used Joe Flacco, who went 4-1 in five starts during the previous regular season. The team also faces questions regarding Nick Chubb’s knee after he suffered a torn MCL and damaged ACL in a Week 2 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers last year. Adding Winston provides a younger option with a big arm to back up Watson, while the team also carries Dorian Thompson-Robinson. Nyheim Hines, who is recovering from a serious jet ski injury, could serve as a primary pass-catching back. The defense also relies on players like Jerome Ford, who rushed for 813 yards in 17 appearances last season. Removing high-priced veterans like Tomlinson clearly indicates the team prefers roster flexibility over expensive depth.