Matchday SUN 22 NOV

MLB

The high cost of keeping Juan Soto

Juan Soto's reported whisper number for a contract sits at $600 million as the Yankees face intense bidding competition from Steve Cohen and the New York Mets. Negotiating with agent Scott Boras presents significant financial risks for franchises seeking to secure the elite slugger.

The high cost of keeping Juan Soto

Boras tactics and market value

Juan Soto remains a unicorn after hitting 41 home runs and driving in 109 runs for the Yankees. The four-time All-Star slugged the Yankees to the World Series with a tenth-inning home run in Cleveland. His agent, Scott Boras, refuses to provide a "takedown price" to interested franchises. This refusal forces owners to increase offers in tens of millions of dollars to satisfy the player. The bidding process involves the "Soto Supreme Court," which includes the player, his mother, and nine uncles. Boras Corp. employs 80 employees, including mathematicians and finance experts, to calculate client worth. Boras uses radio interviews to reach diverse audiences in the home countries of his high-caliber clients. The reported whisper number for Soto sits at $600 million, trailing Shohei Ohtani’s $700 million deal. Soto also recorded 128 hits in 2024, a figure that led the American League.

Contract Component Details
Reported Whisper Number $600 million
Potential 15-year valuation $675 million
Historical benchmark $700 million
2022 rejected offer $440 million
2024 Soto OPS .953

The negotiation landscape remains volatile as teams like the Mets, Dodgers, and Blue Jays fight for his services. The bidding war involves many teams including the Dodgers, Red Sox, and Blue Jays, all of whom seek to capitalize on Soto’s unique ability to hit for power and maintain a high on-base percentage.

Competition from New York rivals

The New York Mets lead the race because Steve Cohen maintains a payroll exceeding $300 million. The Mets signed Soto to a 15-year, $765 million contract after they outbid the Dodgers. The Yankees face pressure to match these figures to avoid falling behind. You likely remember the tension when the Yankees bypassed Freddie Freeman to sign Anthony Rizzo in 2021. The Yankees project a luxury tax of $9.4 million, while the Mets expect to owe $29.9 million. The Mets’ payroll reached $375 million in 2023.

The Los Angeles Dodgers entered negotiations, despite having $70 million in room under the Competitive Balance Tax Threshold. The Red Sox, which possesses an elite farm system, and the Blue Jays held early meetings with the outfielder. The Phillies remain interested because Dave Dombrowski wants to shake up the roster. Bidding involves billionaires who pile money into proposals to secure the player. The Dodgers still have gaps at corner outfield, middle infield, and in their rotation.

Yankees roster vulnerability

The New York Yankees face a massive deficit if they fail to secure Soto. The loss of the outfielder could stall the organization for five to ten years. Fans view him as the missing piece for this championship window. A failure to address his vacancy might trigger a full rebuild. The front office must decide if they can match the deep pockets of Steve Cohen. Soto finished third in the AL MVP voting, hitting .288 with 109 RBIs and 129 walks. Over seven major league seasons, he recorded a .285 batting average with 201 home runs and 592 RBIs.

The decision to replace Soto with Pete Alonso proves a poor strategic move. Alonso offers power but lacks speed and strikes out 23% of the time. The Yankees lineup needs power and more contact, alongside a total overhaul of their defense. They could instead target players like Max Fried or Corbin Burnes to improve their rotation. They could also look at Alex Bregman to improve their athleticism.

Will the Yankees find a way to keep their superstar or will they let him walk to Queens?

Back to top