Matchday MON 16 NOV

NHL

Auston Matthews’ 2026-27 goal-scoring slump recovery explained

Auston Matthews is working to regain his elite scoring form after a drop in shot attempts and shooting percentage following knee surgery. Despite a dip to 13 goals in 26 games, his improved skating and defensive play under coach Craig Berube signal a potential offensive rebound.

Auston Matthews' 2026-27 goal-scoring slump recovery explained

Physicality and skating improvements

Matthews skates better than at any point in the last five years according to GM John Chayka. He arrived in camp lighter after knee surgery ended his 2025-26 season early. That surgery followed a grade 3 MCL tear on March 13, 2026, caused by a hit from Radko Gudas. Matthews underwent surgery in New York City for a grade 3 MCL tear after a hit from Radko Gudas, which resulted in a recovery time of roughly 12 weeks according to team updates. During that matchup, Gudas received a five-minute major for kneeing and a game misconduct. Matthews required assistance to leave the ice. He recently captained Team USA at the 2026 Olympics in Milano Cortina where he scored three goals and recorded seven points in six games. You know the frustration of watching a superstar struggle through rehab. He has managed several injuries recently, including an upper-body injury that required a five-day trip to Germany to visit a specialist. This injury was something he managed during the preseason. Matthews, the number one overall pick in the 2016 NHL Entry Draft, has scored 379 career goals since entering the league. He also became the all-time leading goal scorer for the Maple Leafs by surpassing Mats Sundin. His shot attempts per 60 minutes dropped from 17.4 last season to 13.4 in the first four games of this campaign.

Statistical declines and defensive shift

Matthews has 13 goals in 26 games this season. This production follows a period where his shooting percentage fell from 16.2 percent during the 2023-24 season to 12.3 percent over the last two seasons. Coach Craig Berube wants Matthews to play a more defensive role. While he improves on the defensive side, the team requires him to carry the offense. In the 2024-25 season, he scored 33 goals and 45 assists in 67 games. That performance established a 1.16 points-per-game pace. He scored 69 goals during the 2023-24 season.

Season Goals Shooting %
2023-24 69 16.2%
2024-25 33 12.6%
2025-26 27 11.9%

Matthews holds 379 career goals, which places him ahead of Leon Draisaitl. He recorded 12 points in 11 games after returning from his previous injury. Currently, he sits fourth on the Maple Leafs with 23 points in 24 games this season, following a season where he scored at least 40 goals in each of the previous five seasons. The team needs him to be the primary scoring threat again. He even managed a wrist injury that required surgery during the 2021 offseason.

The offensive transition

The lack of production stems from a drop in shot volume and finishing ability. Matthews generated 1.10 expected goals per 60 minutes at five-on-five last season. That number fell to 0.65 expected goals per 60 minutes in the first four games of 2026-27. He drives play and sets others up with three assists. The team play around him improved, showing an on-ice expected goals share of 63.5 percent. This is an increase from the 46.9 percent share he had last season. The Maple Leafs power play remains a significant opportunity for his return to form. He typically operates from the flank while William Nylander carries the puck and John Tavares works the net front. Matthew Knies provides puck retrieval while Morgan Rielly quarterbacks the unit from the blue line. During his 69-goal season, he took 227 shots. In the 2024-25 season, he took 261 shots. If he increases his shots per game back above four, his old form will return. Will his shooting percentage climb back to the 16 percent range?

Back to top